James Trafford had barely drawn breath from the second save by the time Ezri Konsa had hauled him back to his feet using his own shirt as a hoist. As Spain chased that late equaliser, having clawed it back to 3-2 from 3-0 down, Trafford stopped anything and everything thrown his way in the closing stages, including the double save in the 92nd minute, a pivotal moment as England ended Spain's 43-match unbeaten run.
At that stage, England were down to 10 men, defending with everything they had. The recent reference points were fresh in the mind: the Mexico win in the round of 16 at the Azteca Stadium, Dan Burn immortalised after a heroic performance complete with heading the ball nearly half a pitch. That's the good.
But there was also the bad and ugly: Argentina in the semifinal, as England went 1-0 up, tried to defend their lead, and were dumped out of the World Cup. But this time in Madrid, facing an onslaught from the best team in the world, England were unyielding. It was fitting that it was Burn at the end who headed away Yamal's cross in the final act of the match. But central to how England dragged this over the line was Trafford.
For the first hour, it was all about England's breathless attack. Spain couldn't find a way through England's press, suffocated by their own design. England played with self-belief, and while they were second-best on possession, they controlled the aspects of the match that mattered and built a 3-0 lead. That is, until Elliot Anderson brought down Yamal in the 63rd minute, was issued a red card, and Mikel Oyarzabal scored from the resulting penalty. Ten minutes later, Nico Williams scored Spain's second. Ghosts of Argentina started to materialise in the Metropolitano.
This was Trafford's fifth cap for England. Tuchel has used this Nations League to give him match time, building his bank of international experience. For the last eight years, the England No. 1 spot has been Jordan Pickford's. During that time, he's had Joe Hart, Nick Pope, Jack Butland, Tom Heaton, Alex McCarthy, Dean Henderson, Sam Johnstone and Aaron Ramsdale for competition, but still remained England's first-choice keeper through their semifinal defeat at World Cup 2018, England's run to the final of Euro 2021, the quarterfinal exit in Qatar 2022, the defeat to Spain in the final of Euro 2024 and then that agonising defeat to Argentina last summer. It's Pickford's spot, but that's not to say competition isn't welcome.
Trafford and Dean Henderson are the closest challengers to that No. 1 jersey. Henderson is still working his way back after an ankle injury disrupted the start to his season -- it was he who Tuchel started against France for the bronze medal match on July 18. With Henderson sidelined for the last batch of Nations League matches, Tuchel gave Trafford his chance. He was in goal for England's 3-2 defeat to Spain at Wembley, and then the 2-0 win in Prague. Pickford returned for the 7-0 stroll in Croatia and the 3-0 win over Czechia back at Wembley.
For this double-header, Tuchel started Pickford for the 2-1 win over Croatia last Thursday, but for their "final" against Spain, it was Trafford again. Before kick-off, when asked about the goalkeeping juggling, Tuchel confirmed Pickford remained his No. 1 and explained his thinking.
"Traff gets regular starts now, that's what we wanted. When do I have a chance to see another goalkeeper, if not in the Nations League? If not in high-pressure matches?" Tuchel said. "What happens if Jordan Pickford is injured? So, it's better to test it. Jordan knows about this. At the moment, he's the No. 1 and he just feels a bit of competition, which is good for him."
Tuchel reports that Pickford has bought into the rotation, rather than pushing back. "I thought he'd be less of a fan than he proved to be because he said he totally understands it," Tuchel said. "So very impressive, he did it very well." That all plays into Tuchel's notion of brotherhood being paramount.
It hasn't been an easy couple of years for Trafford, but the promise has always been there. You'd have seen the clips of Trafford's heroics for England in the final of the men's Under-21 Euros in July 2023. It was the 98th minute. England were winning 1-0, but Spain had a penalty. Trafford leapt down to his right to stop Abel Ruiz's penalty, somehow kept out the rebound effort from Aimar Oroz and flung himself at the next effort which flew over.
- England's win over Spain is the statement Tuchel's team has been waiting for
- Rice claims England knew they were going to end Spain's unbeaten run
- Tuchel describes England's 3-2 win over Spain as the best of his tenure
In the summer of 2025, Trafford, at Burnley, had both Newcastle and Manchester City interested. He'd grown up at City so headed back there for £31 million ($41m) with the expectation of being their No. 1. But by Sept. 1, 33 days after he signed, Gianluigi Donnarumma arrived. Trafford's role shifted to cup goalkeeper. He's since spoken to the BBC about how such a shift in status affected his "mental wellbeing", adding: "What a horrendous, horrendous feeling. Not playing. I had to play regularly this season for my own mental wellbeing. You just lose yourself not playing. Maybe I'm different, I don't know, but the feeling of not playing every week, it felt horrendous."
Last summer Trafford went to the World Cup as third choice; his lack of gametime at club level was an issue. A move made sense, and he headed to Leeds for a record-breaking fee for a British goalkeeper of £45m. He's established himself at Leeds as their undisputed No. 1. His performances there have forced him back into Tuchel's thinking to the extent they wanted to give him the opportunity to put some heat on the back of Pickford's neck this season.
"I always believe that one day I could be," Trafford said before these Nations League games. "Every day I try to keep improving to put myself in the best position to be England's No. 1 one day.
"I think everyone in the goalkeeping department with the national team wants to be No. 1 because it's an amazing position to be in."
In Madrid, Trafford played with confidence and a self-assuredness that he deserved to be there. That half an hour post-red card was a defining spell for him. There were a series of excellent moments: the save from Ferran Torres in the 74th minute, and a couple of quickfire saves in the 79th minute as he palmed away Yamal's effort and then kept out Marc Cucurella's. Then, came the highlight-friendly double in the 92nd minute, and the subsequent outpouring of relief and joy (look at Djed Spence who just stood still in disbelief, applauding). Was it Trafford's best save? No, that was when he was on loan at Bolton, playing against Port Vale. Regardless, Tuchel was impressed.
"That's his job, to close the gap. We want competition in all positions," Tuchel said after the Spain win. "We need to see Trafford in high-pressure moments. The obvious save, where he deserves full credit, is the double save at the very end. Absolutely brilliant.
"There was a lot to do in the deep build-up as well, which he did very, very well, with everyone around him. Never lose the concentration, never lose the focus, never lose the vision where to find the free men to overcome the press and put the game to the opponent's half. With everyone else, he was part of a fantastic team performance."
But as for a new No. 1? "There's no need to have a new No. 1," Tuchel said.
Sitting on the bench watching Trafford fling himself around Madrid was Pickford. England next play in March, and you expect Pickford will return in between the sticks. "Tuchel was wise to use him in these games to get competitive caps," one former international goalkeeper told ESPN. "But Pickford has sustained form over a long period of time. The conversation is opening up but Pickford's not doing a lot wrong. Pickford should remain No. 1, with a very good number two there should Pickford lose form, get injured or the natural progression takes over."
Pickford will be 34 at the next Euros, still young for a top keeper. Pickford, now on 94 caps, has retained the faith of Gareth Southgate and now Tuchel. Against Norway at the World Cup, he broke Peter Shilton's England men's record of 18 World Cup appearances. At the time, I asked whether Pickford had been underappreciated by England fans.
"When people talk about the best goalkeepers in the Premier League, they mention David Raya, [Gianluigi] Donnarumma and Alisson [Becker]," Pickford's former Everton teammate Asmir Begovic told ESPN at the time. "Why not Jordan? Everton's an incredible football club, but maybe if he was at Man City or Arsenal, that would give him an edge in perception. When you look at his performances, he's up there with the best of them."
Trafford's performance against Spain has narrowed the gap between Pickford and the chasing pack, but it's still Pickford's shirt to lose.
