NEW YORK -- Defending NWSL champions Gotham FC were eliminated from the 2026 playoffs on Sunday following a 2-1 loss to the Kansas City Current at Icahn Stadium on Randall's Island in which they failed to get a single shot on goal.
It wasn't the first time in this postseason.
Gotham also failed to register a shot on goal in a 1-0 quarterfinal win over Seattle Reign FC last weekend, so for the second straight playoff match the only time it got on the scoresheet was with an own goal.
"It's not good enough," Gotham forward Midge Purce said. "It's not good enough from our back line. We need to do better at producing. I think sometimes it's just exactly what you see. We need to be a bit better in front of goal."
Purce's cross in the 69th minute led to Kansas City defender Laney Rouse deflecting the ball into her own net on an attempted clearance. The goal served as an equalizer after Kansas City midfielder Croix Bethune put her team ahead 20 minutes into the match with a sublime free kick.
Current forward Haley Hopkins latched onto the end of a set piece in the 89th minute for the winning goal, hitting her shot off the underside of the crossbar.
"I think we were kind of our own worst enemy today," Gotham FC midfielder Savannah McCaskill said. "I think at times we played into what they wanted to do and their style of play. They want a very chippy game, they want to get into tackles, they want to draw fouls. They want break up the game, they want to play long.
"And that's not our style. We want to keep the ball, we want to control tempo, and we like to play pretty football. That's what we pride ourselves on."
Gotham was missing its primary playmaker, midfielder Rose Lavelle, at the start of the match due to ongoing neck issues related to a concussion sustained in early October. Gotham head coach Juan Carlos Amoros said ahead of the match that Lavelle also had an issue with her calf.
Lavelle came off the bench at halftime and provided an immediate spark for Gotham.
She made a tackle seconds after Kansas City kicked off the second half, and she earned a foul in a dangerous position of the field with her next touch. The difference between Gotham with and without Lavelle on the field is distinct, and the shift in energy was palpable after the United States international took the field in the second half. Still, Gotham could not muster a shot on goal.
Gotham forward Jaedyn Shaw started, but was questionable coming into the match due to an ankle injury. The health struggles of Lavelle and Shaw late in the season compounded Gotham's injury woes and mid-season roster upheaval.
All-league defender Emily Sonnett sustained a major knee injury in July. Forward Esther González, the club's all-time leading scorer, abruptly left the team in August and signed in Saudi Arabia a few weeks later.
Defender Bruninha and breakout rookie forward Jordynn Dudley each sustained season-ending injuries within days of each other in early October.
On Sunday, Gotham held 65% of possession, but failed to make it count for much.
"We are too vulnerable in transition too many times, and we've been saying it after every single game, pretty much, this season," Gotham defender Jess Carter said. "So, it's the same frustrations for me. I'm a defender. I hate giving up goals, so I think it's something we have to work on going forward if we want to compete at this level and win things. We have to be better to not give up so many transitions."
Sunday's semifinal was played at Icahn Stadium, a 5,000-seat venue with a track around it that typically hosts amateur events, following player dissatisfaction with the field quality at the team's usual home, Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, New Jersey.
