England vs. All Blacks: Key questions for both sides ahead of Nations Championship showdown

England beat the All Blacks 33-19 at Twickenham last year. Warren Little/Getty Images

England against New Zealand is always a highlight in the rugby calendar, and this week's Test at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham is shaping up to be a hugely important one.

Both sides have had mixed years: England with their poor Six Nations and New Zealand with a 3-1 series defeat to South Africa before that loss to Wales last week.

- Rugby Nations Championship permutations: Who can reach grand final?
- Rugby power rankings: Who takes top spot? How far do New Zealand drop?

All Blacks boss Dave Rennie has said there will be an extra edge to Saturday's match given their defeat in Cardiff.

So where could the game be won and lost?

ESPN's Tom Hamilton and James Regan break down the key questions.


Who should be the favourites and why?

Hamilton: The All Blacks are the slight favourites for this. Despite their defeat to Wales, they had several key personnel missing, and they remain in the top three sides in the world. England -- along with Ireland -- are eager to knock on that door, but South Africa, All Blacks and France are just ahead of the rest.

England will have home support, and the momentum of four key wins, but the All Blacks will be desperate to put right the wrongs of Cardiff. Dave Rennie said as much earlier in the week, and when you hear an All Blacks coach saying their team has let their country down, you know they'll be readying a response.

Regan: England should be. They're arguably the form team, playing at home and have a near full crop of players at their disposal. The All Blacks are the bookies' favourites because defeats to England are rare and they're still the No. 2 side in the world.

This game is so finely balanced. England can make a huge statement with another victory over New Zealand, even if they are technically the underdogs.


Who needs a win more, Steve Borthwick or Dave Rennie?

Hamilton: This is one is answered by a coin flip. But overall, Borthwick, just.

Rennie still has some grace given the circumstances in which he landed the job and the way he has built some of the All Blacks' aura back up. The Wales result was dreadful, but this match will be decided by far slimmer margins.

If England win, then it's proof that they have turned a corner after a dismal start to the year. That would make it five on the trot and they can take that momentum into the finals weekend and next year's Six Nations. But a defeat would be a step backwards and pending whoever they play next weekend, we need to see proof of progress. The All Blacks offer that opportunity.

Regan: I disagree. Defeat would be disastrous for the All Blacks. It certainly wouldn't be terminal for Rennie, who has the backing of the playing group, who appear in a much better place than this time last year when Scott Robertson was at the helm. The New Zealand public could just about stomach the series loss to the Springboks given the level that side is playing at, but back-to-back defeats to Wales and England would be a huge blow. It's a must win.

It's unfair, but current All Blacks sides are always compared to their predecessors and having already made some unwanted history last week, this side won't want to back that up with becoming the first team to lose back-to-back games to England for the first time in over 20 years.

Hamilton: Borthwick's risky changes show reward as England run riot over Japan


Are the All Blacks be better prepared than England after their defeat to Wales?

Hamilton: Yes. The Wales result would've given everyone one almighty boot up the behind, and given the pressure and expectation around this team, they will be leaving nothing to chance on Saturday.

Eddie Jones warned England to expect a "violent" backlash from the All Blacks and you can see where he's coming from. The All Blacks rested or were without eight starters for the Wales match and they return for England: Jordie Barrett, Cam Roigard, Damian McKenzie, Codie Taylor, Ethan de Groot, Fabian Holland, Tupou Vaa'i and Will Jordan.

Having Jordan back is a wonderful boost and all will be eager to right wrongs. Just listen to Jordie Barrett to get an insight into the All Blacks' psyche ahead of Saturday: "No one is feeling the pinch more than the players," he said. "We care so much. We try really hard. We train hard. Sometimes that can also get you into trouble. We tried so hard last weekend and almost shot ourselves in the foot. We've got really clear plans this weekend so hopefully they can come off."

Nations Championship reaction: Are Wales back? All Blacks in must-win territory

Regan: One of the hallmarks of great All Blacks sides is how they respond to defeat. Very rarely do they lose two in-a-row. Eddie Jones warned England last week they will be met with violence at Twickenham and the hope will be, from a New Zealand perspective, that the experience against Wales stung so much it can't be repeated.

That's easier said than done against a good England outfit, but Borthwick's side haven't really been tested this month.

They outplayed a dismal Wallabies side and breezed past Japan. So, New Zealand will be more battle hardened and have had more time together given their schedules, but it depends on how they handle the emotion of the last week.


Where would a win and a loss put England's year?

Hamilton: That's a great question. You feel so much of the perception of 2026 hinges on this. The year started with plenty of optimism -- England headed into 2026 with seven wins on the bounce. They beat Wales in the Six Nations, and then things fell apart.

They lost the next four in the championship -- including a first ever loss to Italy -- and fell to the Boks in Johannesburg. But since then, they've been rebuilding. The wins over Fiji and Japan were comprehensive, while the win in Argentina showed real character. The triumph over Australia was also a fine performance, against, admittedly, a poor Wallabies side.

But this offers them a real chance to show how much progress has been made. A win over the All Blacks and suddenly 2026 can be archived as a year where the team grew and clawed itself out of a hole. But a defeat puts even more pressure on next weekend and whoever they play in the finals. Borthwick has already been backed to carry England through to the World Cup, but they need statement wins and to show they have learnt from their mistakes, have sorted discipline and can prove they are World Cup contenders.

Regan: A victory would bring huge amounts of confidence that England can carry into the finals weekend and eventually to the Six Nations. It would ease the pressure further on Borthwick and while it won't be forgotten, it will make this year's disappointing Six Nations campaign more tolerable.

A lot depends on how England play as well. If they go out and execute the attacking, exciting rugby that they have insisted they want to show, then fans will be delighted.

The Twickenham crowd can be a tough one to please at times but nothing raises the fizz levels like a win over the All Blacks. Defeat wouldn't be a catastrophe but it would put England closer to where they were after the Six Nations. It would bring a feeling, externally at least, that they aren't real World Cup contenders at this stage.

We've seen how quickly things can change in rugby this week and the feeling towards this England side feels delicately poised.


Who will be the key player from each side?

Hamilton: For England, this is a huge match for Will Joseph. He scored five tries against Japan on his second cap last weekend and rightly keeps his place for the All Blacks in what will be the sternest test of his career to date. The breakdown battle will be key so Ben Curry needs to have a huge game there, and the lineout needs to stay sturdy.

The half-backs will need to click like they did against Australia but if you're looking for a key player, then Seb Atkinson needs a huge game at inside centre. It's been a problem position for England, and he has the potential to have a huge influence on Saturday's game.

Over at the All Blacks, if they're to defeat England then it'll be down to set piece supremacy and proving they can get this done without the talismanic Ardie Savea. But this is about Beauden Barrett. He wins his 150th cap on Saturday -- an astonishing record, as he becomes just the fourth player and first back to his that tally in the men's game.

On a day where Anton Lienert-Brown also wins his 100th cap, the All Blacks won't be short of emotional energy.

Regan: Beauden Barrett will be big for New Zealand. He was the leader and experienced head in the squad last week and will desperately want to right those wrongs. He and McKenzie need to pick up where they left off against Scotland with that 10-15 axis working smoothly and asking questions of England's defence constantly.

In what will be his 150th Test it feels like an occasion he can make his mark on.

For England, I'll say all the forwards on the bench. It's a luxury for Borthwick to be able to have the experience of Ellis Genge, Luke Cowan-Dickie and Will Stuart to come on, as well as the x-factor of Henry Pollock as well as Greg Fisilau, a dynamic back-row who has impressed in stints against Australia and Japan.

Games against New Zealand are always tight and it's been their strength in recent years to use their replacements to pull away around the 60 minute mark. Englands "Pom Squad" will feel they can do that themselves on Saturday.