Nations Championship reaction: Are Wales back? All Blacks in must-win territory

It was the Nations Championship weekend where the northern hemisphere struck back.

France started things off on Friday evening with a monumental win over South Africa, inspired by the incomparable Antoine Dupont. We thought that would be the headline result of the weekend. But after Argentina edged past Italy 19-14 in Genoa, Wales pulled off arguably the greatest rugby result in their country's history as they defeated the All Blacks 35-28 in Cardiff.

It was the biggest upset the game has seen since Japan downed South Africa in 2015, and for those 55,000 souls there, they can say they witnessed a slice of rugby history as Wales beat New Zealand for the first time since 1953. It was improbably bonkers.

Japan should've taken inspiration from that ahead of their trip to Twickenham, but instead it was a procession for the hosts England who dispatched Eddie Jones' side 78-15. Ireland then beat a poor Fiji side 43-15 in the late match on Saturday to make it two from two in the autumn Tests. And then on Sunday, Scotland outmuscled Australia in an arm wrestle of a match in Edinburgh. That victory meant it was 5-1 to the north across the second weekend of the cross-hemisphere tournament.

That all shakes things up nicely ahead of the final weekend of the league phase. France are in the box seat to top the north's league, with second spot between England, Ireland and Scotland. Over in the south, it's New Zealand or South Africa for who tops it. It's all to play for.

Northern series round two results:

France 21-19 South Africa
Italy 14-19 Argentina
Wales 35-28 New Zealand
England 78-15 Japan
Ireland 43-15 Fiji
Scotland 15-12 Australia


Wales get the belief back

Who'd have thought you'd end up seeing a TikTok of Dewi Lake and Jac Morgan dancing in front of a mirror? A few hours earlier, Wales had come together to face the haka, silhouetted against a huge red light. Little did those 23 players know that, within a couple of hours, they would be elevated to something approaching Welsh deities.

The All Blacks went through their familiar pre-match challenge, but for the next two hours, they were blinded and tormented by red: the bodies underneath their players as they attempted to ground the ball, the wall of Welsh red there at every turn and swarming in their faces as they attempted to find their usual flow. Then there were the red dots darting over for their five tries, and then the 55,000 in the crowd, all cheering -- pleading -- with Wales to get across the line and give them reason to dream again. It must've been a Hitchcockian trauma for the All Blacks.

They'll regroup, but the question for Wales is, where do they go from here? Was this a unicorn of a result? Or is this a standard Wales can maintain? Emotion and adrenaline can do wondrous things in sport for a rugby nation scorned over the past four or so years. How they hurt as they went through those 17 games without a win.

You felt for Dewi Lake and Jac Morgan as they faced the press time and time again, looking for any glimmer of hope to hold on to, while admitting it wasn't good enough. Again and again. But on Saturday, Lake had something to celebrate. They'd finally reached the light at the end of the tunnel. No wonder there are reports that folk are clambering over one another to get a ticket for the Wallabies match next weekend after just 55,000 watched Wales make history against the All Blacks.

There are still fundamental, structural issues within the Welsh game. It's astonishing that eight of those players who beat the All Blacks could have their club wiped from existence in a year or so with either Ospreys or Scarlets facing extinction. So don't for one minute put this historic result down as a triumph for the organisation or proof of progress there - no. This was born from the players and their coaching staff, and years of hurt and pent-up frustration. The Wallabies come to town on Saturday. More of the same please Wales. The game desperately needs them back at their passionate best; there's nowhere like the Principality Stadium when Wales are on song. -- Tom Hamilton.


New Zealand are in must win territory against England

What a difference a week makes in rugby. After their commanding win over Scotland, New Zealand looked to be almost unstoppable. They would simply go to Cardiff, chalk up another routine win and move on to the big one against England. Never mind. The All Blacks made changes, but it was still a side that, on paper, was very capable of beating Wales.

It was a valuable lesson for the less experienced players in the squad and it's a result that leaves Dave Rennie staring down the barrel of an underwhelming first year in charge.

Defeat to England would be their fifth of the year and be cause for concern for one of the tournament favourites ahead of next year's World Cup. -- James Regan.


England give Borthwick welcome headache

England have been warned by their old coach Jones to expect a "violent" response from the All Blacks when they come to town on Saturday. But Steve Borthwick will already expect that full well. They had the measure of the Kiwis this time last year when England swept aside a poor New Zealand side 33-19, but this All Blacks team have had their pride hurt by those unlikely heroes in Wales.

"I'm telling you now, come next weekend, we'll be a damn sight better for this," All Blacks assistant coach Neil Barnes said. And England haven't beaten the All Blacks twice in a row since 2003. So selection is key for this, and for once, Borthwick has the cavalry back.

Ollie Chessum, George Furbank and Seb Atkinson all missed the stroll over Japan through injury, but all should be back in the frame for the Kiwis. That leaves Borthwick with a dilemma: so many of his fringe players impressed in that win over Japan -- so what do you do with someone like Will Joseph who scored five tries? Do you keep him in the team or go for Cadan Murley? What about Max Ojomoh who played with such effortless control at inside centre when you also have Atkinson who did brilliantly against Australia? Freddie Steward was exceptional against Japan, but then again, Furbank was great against the Wallabies, as was Atkinson, as was Chessum. Dilemmas, dilemmas.

All of this is a far different feeling to earlier in the year when England endured their worst ever Six Nations campaign. Back then, selection felt like it was the difference between being handed a chance for redemption or a P45. But now it's down to impressive form, rather than last men standing, or relying on tried and tested contenders to bring England out of a hole. How things change in a couple of months in rugby. Just ask Wales, for starters.

"We need to attack the game from minute one," Maro Itoje said after the Japan game. "If you start poorly, if you're ill-disciplined, it's very difficult for you, but if you're aggressive, if you're disciplined, if you have that mindset to attack everything, then things can open up." -- Hamilton



We're running out of superlatives for Antoine Dupont

No Thomas Ramos, no Romain Ntamack, no Matthieu Jalibert? No worries. Just get Antoine Dupont to play scrum-half and fly-half. He was, of course, supported by Maxime Lucu against South Africa but Dupont somehow managed to go to yet another level. A superb 50-22 set France on their way for their second try, while his vision to find Louis Bielle-Biarrey with the boot for their third was mesmerising.

He thinks of things other players couldn't dream of and executes then more often than not. France are building very nicely. Yes, their scrum was put under huge pressure by the Springboks pack, but the likes of Gregory Alldrit and Mickaƫl Guillard can change momentum in an instant. When the rest of their top players back from injury, they could be unstoppable. -- Regan.


Springboks' mind games fall flat

Just when it looked like it was all quiet from the South Africa camp, Rassie Erasmus attempted to pull a rabbit out the hat, dropping the experienced, premier front-row of Ox Nche, Malcolm Marx and Wilco Louw to the bench. The ploy backfired.

France were up 21-7 by the time Erasmus brought his first-choice front row onto the pitch before half time. In the cold light of day, South Africa will know they had a huge opportunity to win that game even if they didn't play at their best.

Of the decison to change the front-row, Erasmus said: "It was late in the week that we made that call, and up until the captain's practice yesterday we weren't quite sure It was a little bit of an eye on the World Cup, looking at how that combination went. But as we sit here, it didn't work because we lost."

It was a gamble that didn't pay off. The concerning thing for their rivals will be the Springboks rarely make the same mistakes twice. -- Regan.


Australia's attack fails to fire -- again

While the defensive crisis may be over -- for now -- the Wallabies attacking crisis certainly isn't.

The return of Carter Gordon failed to produce the magic fix many had been hoping for in an attack that has failed to fire over four straight losses. Despite some astute play early that helped set up Harry Potter's try in the 11th minute, Gordon produced little else while his backline was close to unsighted in the dour contest.

Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii was absent once again opening up more questions of how he's best used, while Len Ikitau made little impact as Scotland easily wrapped him up, and Tom Wright failed to deliver any spark.

There remains little creativity to their attack with one-out forward runners struggling to bend the line and ball speed at the base of the ruck simply too slow -- Scotland's looked lightning quick in comparison. Turning to aimless contestable kicking endlessly frustrates as hard-earned possession continues to be handed straight back.

Meanwhile, attacking opportunities continue to be spurned with mind-numbing errors and poor discipline. The Wallabies finished with nine line breaks and little to show for it with Scotland's rush defence shutting down any glimpses of attacking threats.

Too flat, too narrow and unimaginative. The Wallabies must find a spark quickly. -- Brittany Mitchell.