The Wallabies have produced their most frustrating performance to date under Les Kiss, falling agonisingly short in a dour contest that was open for the taking, but which they refused to take control of.
The Wallabies were an improved outfit to the one that conceded 45 points just a week earlier to England - especially in defence - but in a game of fine margins and in a tense arm wrestle, it's the small, but crucial, errors and the questionable decision making that were the defining moments in yet another crushing defeat.
Trailing by seven points and with six minutes until halftime, the Wallabies were in the perfect position to level the scores. Securing the lineout on the five-metre line, they began to rumble and within seconds they were over. But just as quickly, it was scrubbed out. Jeremy Williams had wedged himself between Josh Canham and the Scotland defence as they formed the maul, ruling out a much-needed try. A coach-killing error, but frustratingly not the first time the Wallabies have given away such a penalty over the last two months.
Minutes later with the clock ticking towards halftime, the Wallabies were given another chance, winning a scrum penalty inside Scotland's half. Turning down a shot at goal, the Wallabies instead went to the lineout once more.
Scotland held strong in the maul, denying the Wallabies an easy passage to the line and instead forced them to use the ball. After several phases of Wallabies' forwards battering the line but failing to barge their way through, Carter Gordon finally got his hands on the ball and showed an astounding lack of patience and poor game management, kicking for Max Jorgensen on the wing and instead sending the ball into touch. Halftime. Wallabies seven points down.
Foolish and frustrating; they would prove to be the defining moments for the Wallabies in a grim contest that neither side dominated.
The Wallabies' defence was more aligned and showed more aggression and starch from what had been seen over the last two months, conceding just one line break with Fraser McReight leading the tackle stats with 31, while their set-piece dominated, winning multiple scrum penalties and holding its own at the lineout.
Their defensive work rate was huge with Scotland's ball speed allowing their forwards to constantly batter at the line and Finn Russell to create some sweeping moves out the back. It resulted in an early try to Matt Fagerson after Scotland showed patience to draw the Wallabies in tight before sending wide to the unmarked flanker. A second would come almost 20 minutes later with Jack Dempsey battering through from close range after several phases.
But for much of the 80 minutes the Wallabies refused to break.
Their second half effort was especially impressive. Playing a man down through a 10-minute period following Billy Pollard's yellow card for head-on-head contact, first Canham got up high to disrupt and steal Scotland's lineout just metres from their line, before they repelled multiple attacking raids. Pilfers from McReight and a breakdown win to Taniela Tupou stopped any attacking momentum.
However strong their defence was, though, their attack failed to deliver.
Gordon's return from a broken leg was lacklustre. While the fly-half helped to set up Harry Potter's opening try -- holding the ball up just enough to create the overlap on the left side with Potter keeping his feet in the tackle inches from the sideline before working to get the ball down -- he failed to produce much else with some of his decision-making proving costly.
The Wallabies lacked patience or creativity with ball in hand with Ryan Lonergan and Gordon constantly putting the ball to the sky, and often handing hard-earned possession straight back to Scotland after one-out forward runners found themselves isolated and unable to dent the line.
Lonergan's decision to send an up-and-under kick for the quiet Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii in the 50th minute, as the Wallabies attempted to break into Scotland's 22 for the first time in the second half, was the perfect example of a team that had no answers to an unbreakable defence.
Crucially the Wallabies lacked ball speed, any attacking gains slowed down at the breakdown allowing the Scotland defence too much time to reset.
The ball simply moved from side-to-side, any back play movement shut down quickly by rushing defence, while Len Ikitau and Tom Wright struggled to provide any spark for the floundering attack. Meanwhile, yet more questions will be asked of Suaalii after he went unsighted once again, carrying the ball for just seven metres.
Despite the lack of enterprise, the Wallabies made nine line breaks but had little to show for them, with their attack finally springing to life in the final minutes, with Tate McDermott sniping around the edge of the ruck and Ben Donaldson bringing some depth in attack that saw Jorgensen over the line and setting up a fast finish.
It was all too little too late though, with Wright taken into touch as the Wallabies attempted to run the ball from their own half in a brazen effort to steal the win after the siren. Instead, the Wallabies walk away from Murrayfield on four straight losses - eight straight in the northern hemisphere - and looking no closer to ending their horror run.
