Giants QB J.J. McCarthy's growth is showing in the numbers

play
Stephen A.: 'John Harbaugh should be ashamed of himself' after Giants' loss (2:24)

EAST RUTHERFORD, N.J. -- Quarterback J.J. McCarthy played "very well" in Thursday night's 24-21 loss to the Washington Commanders, according to coach John Harbaugh. He set a career high with 293 yards passing and had the New York Giants moving the ball the entire evening.

The night ended with McCarthy throwing his first interception since he entered the game in the fourth quarter last month against the New Orleans Saints. It still didn't come close to ruining the overall performance or change the impression that McCarthy has been impressive since becoming the team's starting quarterback.

It's not perfect, but it's promising.

"There were some plays made, he made some throws, scrambled. I thought J.J. played very well," Harbaugh said.

He later added that McCarthy "threw some dimes" and made some "great throws." McCarthy also seemed to be more comfortable in the pocket than last week against the Philadelphia Eagles, when he took five sacks, and did better getting through his progressions. In a lot of ways, he barely resembled the quarterback who struggled his first two seasons with the Minnesota Vikings, the first because of injury and then as he got acclimated to the NFL game.

McCarthy, the No. 10 pick for the Vikings in the 2024 NFL draft, was traded to the Giants in late September for a fifth-round pick. He was pleased but not blown away with his performance Thursday night.

"There's things I could've done better," he said afterward.

That just goes to show how far McCarthy has come in such a short time. He was the third-stringer in Minnesota just six weeks ago.

It may be only three starts and four games playing for the Giants, but the numbers are staggering. They suggest a much different quarterback than the one who started 10 games for the Vikings last season.

McCarthy's QBR has skyrocketed from 36.1 to 56.3 this season. His completion percentage has gone from second to last among quarterbacks with at least 100 pass attempts at 57.6% to 63.5% with the Giants. His completion percentage over expectation has risen from an awful minus-5.2 with Minnesota (second worst only to Chicago's Caleb Williams last year) to plus-5.0, which puts him fifth among all quarterbacks this season.

His off-target throw percentage has dropped from 19.3% to 13.5% and his yards per dropback has gone from a bad 5.71 to 8.04 with the Giants, which is fourth in the NFL. Even McCarthy's precision passing percentage has gone from 45.3% (dead last) to a more than respectable 53.5%.

The improvement in his accuracy has been among the most noticeable differences. It was on display against the Commanders. Perhaps McCarthy's best throw came when he was under pressure with a blitzer in his face early in the fourth quarter. He hit tight end Isaiah Likely in stride with a laser through a tight window over the middle for a 66-yard catch-and-run touchdown.

"That's probably as good a play as you're going to see in the National Football League all season, honestly," Harbaugh said.

It has McCarthy and the Giants feeling confident about this season and his future. The 23-year-old quarterback has been a good fit with offensive coordinator Matt Nagy's scheme and in New York.

At least so far.

"I just feel really good in terms of my preparation going into every week. They are very detailed in terms of what they want from me, what the intent is every single play. There is no gray area going into each play and I just really appreciate the heck out of that," he said. "It is all about building, constantly growing, and that is what we are focused on. Being in the league for a little over two years now, seeing defenses that I have seen before and running concepts that I have run before, everything seems to be slowing down for me.

"Just being able to keep stacking and keep growing 1% every single day and I am just so blessed to be in this offense and so blessed to be a part of this organization."

The spike in numbers is not all apples to apples. McCarthy is a year older, with more experience and in a completely different situation. But there clearly has been progress, especially in understanding the professional game. It has been apparent when he faces zone defenses.

McCarthy is averaging 10.9 yards per attempt against zone defenses through four games as a Giants quarterback. That's second best of any quarterback behind only Houston's C.J. Stroud since McCarthy entered the lineup. He was at a paltry 6.8 yards per attempt against zone defenses last season, which ranked him near the bottom of the league.

In fact, McCarthy's expected points added against zone defense of 0.22 is tops among all quarterbacks this season. It seems to be a sign that his understanding of the game is improving under the guidance of Nagy and quarterbacks coach Brian Callahan and trending in the right direction with more playing time and experience.

"I think he's done a great job," Harbaugh said Friday.

It's still early, but maybe, just maybe, the Giants hit on something here.