Aaron Rodgers makes fantasy football history, now No. 2 on all-time scoring list

Illustration by ESPN

Congratulations, Aaron Rodgers, on another significant career milestone!

With his 27-yard touchdown pass to tight end Pat Freiermuth in the fourth quarter of the Pittsburgh Steelers' Week 10 game against the Cincinnati Bengals, Rodgers moved into second place all-time in fantasy football scoring. That play pushed his career total to 5,191.12 fantasy points, passing Drew Brees (5,188.92) on the all-time list.

Rodgers finished his day with 15.62 fantasy points, and he has 132.76 fantasy points for the season, 18th among quarterbacks.

This comes after Rodgers broke a tie with Peyton Manning (539) to move into third place exclusively in career touchdown passes, with 540.

Rodgers' career fantasy prowess is especially impressive if examining his contributions on a rate basis. He entered Week 8 having averaged 19.1 fantasy points across 271 career games, easily the most among any quarterback with at least 150 games played. In Rodgers' 264 career starts entering the week, he averaged 19.5 points, again easily the most among quarterbacks with at least 150 starts. Note, however, that among active quarterbacks, Josh Allen (22.4), Lamar Jackson (21.7) and Patrick Mahomes (21.3) comprise the top three in points per game as starters, if we lower the threshold to at least 100 career starts.

Rodgers' chances at reaching the top of the scoring list is long, to say the least. Tom Brady, who made 333 career starts (plus two relief appearances) over a 23-year NFL career, holds the all-time record for scoring, with 5,944.36.

Brady played until he was 45 years, 166 days old, or two years and 196 days older than Rodgers is today. To put the differential in their scoring into perspective, if Rodgers were to play until exactly the age that Brady was when he retired, he would need to play every one of 43 games -- assuming the league doesn't again expand the schedule during that time -- and average at least 17.6 fantasy points in them. That's a tall order, considering Rodgers has averaged 14.1 (2022), 15.1 (2024) and 14.1 (2025) fantasy points in his three most recent fully healthy seasons, as well as 16.0 over the first seven weeks of this season.

Nevertheless, none of that should discount anything Rodgers has accomplished over his career. His resume includes four MVP awards (2011, 2015, 2020-21), a Super Bowl win (Super Bowl XLV), one fantasy football scoring title (2011), four seasons leading all quarterbacks in fantasy scoring (2009, 2011, 2014, 2016) and 10 seasons with at least 300 fantasy points scored (2009-12, 2014-16, 2018, 2020-21). Rodgers also joins Brady as the only players to score at least 250 fantasy points in a season played entirely after his 40th birthday (2024, 256.58).

It's yet another highlight in what's a clear Hall of Fame career, both on the gridiron and in fantasy football.