College Football Playoff top 12 projection after Week 12

play
Kirby Smart emphasizes patience in Georgia's dominance on the road (1:12)

Before the College Football Playoff balloons to 24 teams next season, there's one more set of Power 4 conference championship games to be played.

Georgia has earned a spot in the historic SEC finale. Utah has clinched a place in the Big 12 title game. And Miami and Wake Forest will be featured in the ACC's encore performance.

The Big Ten?

Well, that's a bit of a question mark following UCLA's first loss of the season. So is how far the Bruins fall on Tuesday night in the CFP selection committee's fourth ranking of the season.

The group's top 12 teams are unlikely to change, but the order will certainly shift.

The Bruins could sink behind Tennessee and now have more questions about their quarterback situation for the committee to consider. And is BYU still safe following its triple-overtime win against Kansas, one of the Big 12's bottom teams?

Based on what the committee did in its third ranking, plus historical knowledge and an understanding of the criteria and protocol, here's a look at what it might do with its fourth ranking.

Jump to:
Ranking | Bracket

Projecting the top 12

1. Georgia Bulldogs (10-1)

Why they could be here: Saturday's victory at South Carolina was the Bulldogs' fifth against an opponent currently ranked in the committee's top 25 (along with Oklahoma, Alabama, Florida, Ole Miss). The Bulldogs have the best combination of eye test and résumé after earning their fourth road win. Georgia entered Week 12 ranked No. 1 in overall efficiency, No. 1 in offensive efficiency and No. 7 in defensive efficiency. The committee also will consider that South Carolina quarterback LaNorris Sellers returned to the starting lineup from injury and that still wasn't enough for the Gamecocks to overcome the SEC's best scoring defense.

Why they could be lower: It's unrealistic to think the committee would drop Georgia at this point, especially after an away win against a ranked SEC opponent.

Need to know: Georgia clinched a spot in the SEC championship game. On Selection Day, the No. 1 seed will get to choose its CFP quarterfinal bowl and pick the CFP semifinal bowl it would advance to with a quarterfinal win. The Chick-fil-A Peach Bowl in nearby Atlanta is hosting a quarterfinal this year. Georgia would then choose between the Capital One Orange Bowl and the Allstate Sugar Bowl for a semifinal.

Remaining regular-season game: Next Saturday vs. Georgia Tech. The rival Yellow Jackets are now an eight-loss team, and ESPN's Football Power Index (FPI) gives the Bulldogs a 98.2% chance to win at home.


2. Utah Utes (11-0)

Why they could be here: The Utes are the last undefeated team remaining following Saturday's win at TCU and UCLA's loss at Michigan. Victories against Houston, BYU and Arizona highlight their résumé, and the Utes entered Week 12 ranked No. 1 in ESPN's strength of record metric. The Utes are hovering around the 50th-ranked schedule strength, though, which is significantly lower than Georgia's (No. 25 entering Saturday).

Why they could be higher: There could be some committee members who vote in favor of Utah's undefeated record and overall résumé strength over Georgia, which lost at home to Auburn (7-4).

Need to know: Utah clinched a spot in the Big 12 championship game, but its opponent will be determined in Week 13. Even if the Utes lose that and finish as the Big 12 runner-up, their place in the playoff is nearly a lock. The problem is if Utah loses to West Virginia on Friday and doesn't win the Big 12.

Remaining regular-season game: Friday vs. West Virginia. The FPI gives Utah at least a 90% chance to win at home.


3. Texas Longhorns (9-2)

Why they could be here: Without UCLA wedged between Alabama and Texas, the committee will take a closer look at these two-loss teams side by side. The Longhorns have had a case for a few weeks to be the committee's top two-loss team, and this could be the week they make the jump. Texas has won five straight games, and the Sept. 26 victory at Tennessee continues to be one of the Longhorns' best after the Vols beat LSU by double digits on Saturday. The Longhorns' résumé took a bit of a hit in Week 12 after Ohio State lost. It has helped Texas that the two teams it lost to -- Oklahoma and Florida -- both cracked the top 25 in the committee's third ranking and both won on Saturday. Texas entered Week 12 with the No. 2-ranked strength of schedule and ranked No. 5 in ESPN's strength of record metric. The committee has rewarded Texas for its defense to this point, which is ranked No. 1 in efficiency, according to ESPN Analytics.

Why they could be lower: The committee could keep it status quo since both Alabama and Texas won convincingly. It would be hard for the committee to justify dropping Texas behind Notre Dame or Miami after a convincing win, especially considering all three contenders played unranked opponents.

Need to know: One of the reasons the committee has justified ranking Texas behind Alabama is that the Longhorns have been so inconsistent offensively -- not just game to game but at times quarter to quarter. That wasn't the case on Saturday, as quarterback Arch Manning accounted for three first-half touchdowns and Texas distanced itself from Arkansas by halftime.

Remaining regular-season game: Friday at Texas A&M. It's a short week for both teams, but the FPI projects the Longhorns to win their third SEC road game in the four weeks.


4. Alabama Crimson Tide (9-2)

Why they could be here: A lopsided win against Chattanooga won't impress the selection committee, but the group has consistently rewarded the Crimson Tide for the rest of their résumé. Alabama's best wins continue to lose their luster, though, as Kentucky lost to Missouri on Saturday, South Carolina fell to Georgia and LSU was beaten by Tennessee. Those Vols beat Alabama by 16 points. The committee isn't punishing Alabama for losing a close game to No. 1 Georgia on Oct. 10, and chairman Hunter Yurachek has repeatedly pointed to the Tide's game film as justification for its ranking, along with its schedule. The committee has been impressed by Alabama's scoring margin, which was nearly 23 points per game against SEC teams, and Yurachek said the Tide is ranked in the top 20 in the CFP's relative scoring defense and in the top five in relative scoring offense.

Why they could be higher: The committee could still believe Alabama is a more consistent team, particularly on offense, and keep the Tide ahead of Texas.

Need to know: Alabama hasn't clinched a spot in the SEC title game, and it is looking up at both Texas and Tennessee in the conference standings. Georgia's opponent in the championship tilt will be determined in Week 13.

Remaining regular-season game: Next Saturday vs. Auburn. Anything can happen in the Iron Bowl -- and anything usually does. The Tigers have won three straight games since losing at Ole Miss on Halloween, but the Tide will have home-field advantage.


5. Notre Dame Fighting Irish (10-1)

Why they could be here: The head-to-head win against Miami will keep Notre Dame ahead of the Hurricanes, and UCLA's loss will likely bump the Fighting Irish up a spot. A win against a mediocre SMU team probably isn't enough to push Notre Dame higher, though, as all of the teams ranked above the Irish have more impressive résumés. Notre Dame has a rare combination of a good win (Miami) and a good loss (at BYU), as both teams are in the CFP top 10.

Why they could be ... : It's hard to make a case for the Irish to be higher or lower. Notre Dame should jump UCLA following the Burins' loss at Michigan. The Irish don't have a strong enough résumé to jump Alabama or Texas, and the head-to-head win against the Canes keeps them ahead of Miami.

Need to know: The Irish are just out of range of a first-round bye, and ending the season with a win at Syracuse probably won't push Notre Dame into one of the top four spots. The SEC and Big 12 title game results could, though. If Texas clinches a spot in the SEC championship against Georgia and loses, the three-loss Longhorns would almost certainly fall behind the Irish. It's also possible Utah drops if it loses in the Big 12 title game.

Remaining regular-season game: Next Saturday at Syracuse. The Orange are still trying to become bowl eligible, and it could be a lot more difficult without starting quarterback Steve Angeli, who left Saturday's game with an injury. He had a sling on his throwing arm on the sideline in the loss to Boston College.


6. Miami Hurricanes (10-1)

Why they could be here: The Canes will likely get a bump because UCLA drops after its loss at Michigan, and Miami's win at Wake Forest is now better than UCLA's win at Oregon. (Surprise.) Miami's loss at Notre Dame is also better than UCLA's loss at unranked Michigan. The committee has respected that Miami continues to find ways to win without star receiver Malachi Toney; and on Saturday against Virginia Tech, the Canes won in spite of quarterback Darian Mensah's two interceptions and no touchdowns. While the Hokies aren't ranked, the committee will still respect the victory against a 6-5 ACC team.

Why they could be lower: It's possible the committee doesn't drop UCLA below Miami.

Need to know: Miami clinched a spot in the ACC championship game, where it will face Wake Forest, which also secured a spot with its win against Georgia Tech and Miami's win against the Hokies. It's the ideal matchup for the ACC, as there is a strong chance the conference runner-up will still finish in the committee's top 11 on Selection Day, depending on how the game unfolds. If Miami loses, it could claim a regular-season win against the eventual ACC champs, as the Canes won 33-20 at Wake Forest on Sept. 18. That scenario helped Alabama last year get in as the SEC runner-up after losing to Georgia because the Tide had defeated the Bulldogs during the regular season.

Remaining regular-season game: Next Saturday vs. Boston College. Miami should be a heavy favorite at home against the 5-6 Eagles. But now that the Canes have locked up a spot in the ACC championship game, they would be guaranteed a spot in the playoff as the ACC winner even if they suffered a loss to a bad Boston College team. The problem is if Miami somehow stumbles to the Eagles and doesn't win the ACC. Then it's out.


7. UCLA Bruins (10-1)

Why they could be here: It was only the Bruins' first loss of the season, and it was on the road and in triple overtime against one of the nation's best defenses. The Oct. 10 win at Oregon continues to hold value in the committee meeting room, as the Ducks should hold steady at No. 13 this week. UCLA would likely fall behind Miami, though, because the Canes' lone loss was at Notre Dame, while UCLA fell to an unranked Michigan team trying to qualify for a bowl game.

Why they could be lower: UCLA entered Week 12 with the worst strength of schedule of any of the committee's top 12 contenders (No. 69), and its previously unblemished record helped the group look past that. Now that the Bruins have lost, it comes under the microscope a bit more because UCLA's résumé will be compared with those of the other one-loss teams. UCLA's offense has been average, and while the committee has respected the Bruins' ability to find ways to keep winning with backup quarterback Ty Dieffenbach, he suffered what appeared to be a serious injury in the loss to Michigan. It was clear the team isn't the same with third-string quarterback Madden Iamaleava leading the offense, which isn't entirely unexpected considering he is an inexperienced sophomore who has thrown the ball just eight times this campaign.

Need to know: UCLA missed its chance to clinch a spot in the Big Ten title game on Saturday, but it can still earn a place in the game and win the league, and that could bump it up on Selection Day. UCLA could play a CFP quarterfinal game at home in the Rose Bowl if the Bruins are seeded high enough that they can choose it -- and another top-four seed such as Utah doesn't snag it first. On Selection Day this year, the No. 1 seed gets to choose its quarterfinal bowl. The No. 2 seed then chooses from the three remaining CFP bowls, which this season include the Fiesta, Cotton, Rose and Peach bowls. The No. 3 seed follows, and the No. 4 seed is assigned to the last remaining bowl.

Remaining regular-season game: Next Saturday vs. USC. This will be only the second CFP top 25 opponent UCLA has faced, and while a loss might not eliminate the Bruins, it could sink them into dangerous territory. A win would earn UCLA a spot in the Big Ten title game.


8. Tennessee Volunteers (9-2)

Why they could be here: The committee has made it clear it thinks two-loss Alabama is better than two-loss Tennessee in spite of the Oct. 17 head-to-head result, and it seems unlikely to change given Saturday's results. There will likely continue to be enough teams ranked ahead of Tennessee that the separation between the Vols and Bama continues to exist during the voting process. The Vols have won three straight since their Oct. 24 loss at South Carolina, and they beat unranked LSU on Saturday in convincing fashion.

Why they could be lower: Tennessee had three turnovers against LSU and was aided by the Tigers' 16 penalties for 98 yards. The committee will likely have questions about Tennessee's revolving door at quarterback with Faizon Brandon and George MacIntyre, who wasn't fully healed from a knee injury. The Vols were 4-of-17 on third downs and had 308 yards of total offense. Beating an unranked, five-loss LSU team doesn't carry much weight, though the committee does reward teams for wins against opponents .500 or better.

Need to know: If the committee bumps the Vols up to No. 8 following the win, they will be in position to earn the last first-round home game, which is awarded to teams seeded Nos. 5 to 8.

Remaining regular-season game: Next Saturday at Vanderbilt. The FPI gives Tennessee more than an 80% chance to prevail.


9. Wake Forest Demon Deacons (10-1)

Why they could be here: Sheer dominance reminiscent of last season's Indiana Hoosiers. Wake Forest has scored at least 41 points in five of its past six outings, including in Week 12 against Georgia Tech. Yurachek said Wake Forest is ranked in the top 10 in both relative scoring offense and defense, which are two statistics the committee uses internally and has relied on heavily throughout the playoff era. Wake Forest also has a road win against Louisville, which popped into the committee's top 25 last week. The way Wake Forest won Saturday, coupled with BYU needing triple overtime to beat a sub-.500 Kansas team, boosted the Demon Deacons ahead of the Cougars.

Why they could be lower: Georgia Tech is now an eight-loss team. And while the Deacs have been recording some eye-popping stats, they've been compiled against one of the worst schedules of the listed contenders, according to ESPN Analytics. Wake Forest also lost to Miami, the only ranked opponent beyond Louisville the Deacs have faced. BYU's victory against Notre Dame trumps Wake's best win against Louisville.

Need to know: The higher Wake Forest creeps up in the committee's top 12, the more difficult it will be for the group to justify dropping the Deacs out of the playoff on Selection Day if they finish as a two-loss ACC runner-up. Historically, how those contests unfold plays a role in how the committee evaluates the losers of the Power 4 conference championship games. Last season, BYU was knocked out of the field because it lost to Texas Tech twice -- once during the regular season and again in the Big 12 title game. But how BYU lost -- convincingly both times -- was a major reason. If Wake Forest loses a close game, it could have a different result.

Remaining regular-season game: Next Saturday vs. Duke. The Blue Devils are a talented team capable of an upset, but they're coming off a 20-10 loss to Clemson. Duke gave Miami fits on Nov. 14 for the bulk of the game before falling 36-25. Wake Forest has clinched a spot opposite Miami in the ACC title game set for the following week.


10. BYU Cougars (9-2)

Why they could be here: Saturday's performance wasn't pretty, but they didn't lose, and the Oct. 17 home win against No. 5 Notre Dame is still carrying the Cougars' résumé. When explaining the third CFP ranking, Yurachek said BYU's triumph against the Irish was what had BYU ahead of Wake Forest, but that line was blurred on Saturday considering the different ways both teams won. Needing triple overtime to beat a 4-7 Kansas team will raise some eyebrows in the committee meeting room after BYU already heightened some doubts among the group following its 39-31 double-overtime loss at UCF on Oct. 24. A close loss to Utah isn't hurting the Cougars, especially considering it was on the road against their rival, but BYU's vulnerabilities have been exposed in the back half of the schedule. Still, BYU entered Week 12 with a strength of schedule ahead of both Indiana and Texas Tech, according to ESPN Analytics.

Why they could be lower: BYU has lost two of its past five games, and it struggled against a Kansas team that has just two wins this season against Power 4 opponents (Baylor and West Virginia).

Need to know: Even if BYU doesn't play in the Big 12 title game, it can still get into the playoff along with the conference champion -- as long as it is Utah. If the committee keeps the ranking status quo and Texas Tech is at No. 12, it's still going to be out as the Big 12 runner-up, unless upsets happen above it. If Texas Tech wins the Big 12, though, and Utah finishes as a one-loss Big 12 runner-up, Texas Tech would clinch a spot as the champ and Utah would likely be in, which could bump BYU out.

Remaining regular-season game: Next Saturday vs. Cincinnati. The Bearcats snapped a three-game losing streak Saturday with a home win against Colorado, and they managed to upset Texas Tech 37-24 on Oct. 24.


11. Indiana Hoosiers (9-2)

Why they could be here: Indiana has only one win against a CFP top 25 opponent -- USC -- and now it has a loss to an unranked team in Washington, but the Hoosiers have played a tougher schedule than Texas Tech and a comparable lineup to that of BYU, according to ESPN Analytics. The difference is that BYU has a statement win against Notre Dame and another top-20 win against No. 19 Arizona. It helped the Hoosiers that Nebraska beat Ohio State, as IU's 20-17 win in Lincoln on Oct. 10 is one of its résumé highlights. The committee will likely consider how difficult it is to travel to Washington and that it was a close game against the Huskies, but questions around Indiana's offense will resurface. For the second time in two games, Indiana switched quarterbacks, this time benching Grant Wilson for former starter Josh Hoover. The committee also has rewarded IU this season for its stingy defense, but the Hoosiers allowed 14 points in the first quarter in Seattle. The second loss likely knocks the Hoosiers down but not out -- unless they fall as far as No. 12.

Why they could be lower: Texas Tech has only one loss but two CFP top 25 wins -- against Arizona and Houston. Indiana has struggled in multiple games this season, needing overtime to beat both Michigan and Minnesota, and it has one of the worst special teams units in the country.

Need to know: With the defeat, Indiana will likely drop out of range to host a first-round game, which is awarded to teams seeded Nos. 5 to 8.

Remaining regular-season game: Next Saturday vs. Purdue. The Hoosiers should be heavy favorited against 3-8 Purdue, especially at home.


12. Texas Tech Red Raiders (10-1)

Why they could be here: The Red Raiders have won back-to-back Big 12 road games, and they have two victories against CFP top 20 teams in No. 20 Houston and No. 19 Arizona. Their resounding 52-27 triumph at Oklahoma State on Nov. 14 came when the Cowboys had just cracked the committee's top 25, but when compared to BYU and Indiana, the Red Raiders have the weakest strength of schedule of the group, according to ESPN Analytics. And while BYU struggled mightily to beat Kansas, the Cougars still have wins against Notre Dame and Arizona. Indiana has a second loss but has been a stronger team statistically, particularly on defense.

Why they could be higher: It depends on how far the committee drops the Hoosiers. The Red Raiders have one more CFP top 25 win than the Hoosiers -- and now one fewer loss. Indiana needed overtime to beat both Michigan and Minnesota, and the Hoosiers came up short in overtime at Washington. Seattle is a notoriously difficult place to play, though, and IU's narrow home loss to Ohio State on Oct. 17 was by a foot -- literally. With only one win against a CFP top 25 opponent (USC) and now a second loss, it's possible the Hoosiers fall as far as No. 12.

Need to know: If the playoff were today, Texas Tech would be bumped out of the bracket to make room for Boise State, which would be guaranteed a spot as the committee's highest-ranked Group of 6 team.

Remaining regular-season game: Thursday vs. TCU. The Red Raiders haven't clinched a spot in the Big 12 title game but can with a win.

Bracket

Based on the rankings above, the seeding would be:

First-round byes

No. 1 Georgia (SEC champ)
No. 2 Utah (Big 12 champ)
No. 3 Texas
No. 4 Alabama

First-round games

On campus, Dec. 18 and 19

No. 12 Boise State (highest Group of 6) at No. 5 Notre Dame
No. 11 Indiana at No. 6 Miami (ACC champ)
No. 10 BYU at No. 7 UCLA (Big Ten champ)
No. 9 Wake Forest at No. 8 Tennessee

Quarterfinal games

Vrbo Fiesta Bowl on Dec. 30, and Chick-fil-A Peach Bowl, Goodyear Cotton Bowl Classic and Rose Bowl Game presented by Prudential on Jan. 1.

No. 12 Boise State/No. 5 Notre Dame winner vs. No. 4 Alabama
No. 11 Indiana/No. 6 Miami winner vs. No. 3 Texas
No. 10 BYU/No. 7 UCLA winner vs. No. 2 Utah
No. 9 Wake Forest/No. 8 Tennessee winner vs. No. 1 Georgia