How Patriots' top 10 earners have fared: A.J. Brown, Christian Gonzalez, more

play
McAfee & Co. speculate who will replace injured Drake Maye (2:22)

FOXBOROUGH, Mass. -- Bang for the buck it is not.

The New England Patriots are 5-5 and reeling after two blowout losses that included a season-altering fibula injury to quarterback Drake Maye that is expected to sideline him deep into the regular season. One main reason why? The majority of their highest-paid players aren't producing.

The Patriots rank 11th in cash spending this year. They were ninth in 2025 and 15th in 2024. And the minimal return on investment is striking.

Mike Vrabel's team has a bye this week, providing an opportunity to step back and assess why the season hasn't unfolded as anticipated. Here is a deeper dive on the top 10 earners and their production.

1. CB Christian Gonzalez: $33.75 million per year

Gonzalez was signed to a four-year, $135 million deal in September that made him the league's highest-paid cornerback in average per year. But according to NFL Next Gen Stats, Gonzalez has allowed 12 receptions for 271 yards with three touchdowns and one interception over the past two games. He had a missed tackle that contributed to Amon-Ra St. Brown's 56-yard tone-setting touchdown last Sunday, and it came after the Packers attacked him relentlessly the week prior.

"When your best players don't play good, you don't have much of a chance in this league. So, we expect a lot more. He expects a lot more," Vrabel said of Gonzalez after the Packers game. "We need more from him and everybody else. It wasn't just him. Again, we got to be able to coach and be prepared, and then we have to execute. Just like it is every single week when we don't win, it's all of us, and it starts with me."

Gonzalez has played 78% of the defensive snaps, having missed wins in Weeks 4 and 5 with a shoulder injury.


2. WR A.J. Brown: $32 million per year

It is hard to fathom how poorly it has gone for Brown, who suffered a high ankle sprain in the third quarter of the season opener and hasn't recovered since. He has played in just four games, totaling 11 receptions for 128 yards and no touchdowns, also missing two games because of a knee flare-up. He is now sidelined again because of a hamstring injury.

How much could Brown realistically control? How much is due to how the Patriots played him upon his return from the high ankle sprain (101 of 122 possible snaps in a span of five days)? And how much is just bad injury luck?

Those are burning questions and highlight how disappointing his acquisition for a 2028 first-round pick and 2027 fifth-round pick has been for the Patriots. Brown has struggled to catch the ball (three drops in the game upon his return), although that wasn't the case in training camp, when things looked much more promising.


3. DT Milton Williams: $26 million per year

Starting every game this season and playing 67% of the defensive snaps, Williams has amassed 23 tackles and two sacks, while his 19% pass rush win rate ranks ninth in the NFL among interior defensive tackles. He is his own harshest critic, saying last Sunday's loss to the Lions was the worst game he has played in his six-year NFL career as the Patriots were dominated at the line of scrimmage.

Earlier in the year, Williams noted he was working to overcome increased attention from opponents with double-teams, acknowledging there were times he allowed it to affect him mentally. He is being double-teamed on 76% of his pass rushes (36th in NFL) with a pass rush win rate vs. double-teams of 16.8% (50th).

Despite his lower production, he has assumed a leadership role. He implemented a player-driven fine system for linemen last week if they jumped offside or were penalized for encroachment, a result of the team having seven of those infractions in a two-game span.


4. DT Christian Barmore: $21 million per year

A diminished role (42% of snaps) and modest production (11 tackles, 4.5 sacks) foreshadow that Barmore's future standing with the team is no guarantee, especially since he has no guaranteed money remaining after this year on the four-year, $84 million extension he signed in 2024.

His 21% pass rush win rate ranks seventh among interior defensive tackles. Nose tackle Cory Durden (49%) is playing more than him, and Barmore is coming off a game in which he amassed just 22 snaps, fewest among defensive tackles.


5. CB Carlton Davis III: $18.6 million per year

When the Patriots made Davis one of their big free agent signings of Vrabel's initial class of 2025, the idea was to play "cat coverage" on the outside with him and Gonzalez -- "You got this cat, I got that cat." But there have been too many catnaps between them, and Davis sustaining a neck injury in the season opener has limited him to just five games (27 tackles, two passes defended).


6. WR Romeo Doubs: $17 million per year

Currently on injured reserve (scapula), Doubs has played in six games (36% of snaps) and has 14 catches for 261 yards and three touchdowns. He had a costly dropped pass in the season opener but seemed to be coming on before sustaining the injury while landing hard in the end zone on a 42-yard diving touchdown grab.


7. OLB Harold Landry III: $14.5 million per year

Landry played for Vrabel in Tennessee (2018-2023), and it helped him land a three-year, $43.5 million deal as part of Vrabel's first free agent class. Landry was voted a captain and totaled 8.5 sacks in 2025 but acknowledged he didn't have the same explosiveness after hurting his knee in a Week 6 game. Then came this offseason when he had an undisclosed injury that landed him on the reserve/physically unable to perform list, where he has remained all season.


8. LG Alijah Vera-Tucker: $14 million per year

Currently on injured reserve because of his hamstring, Vera-Tucker had been solid in working between second-year left tackle Will Campbell and second-year center Jared Wilson, and that vision was what led the team to sign him to a three-year, $42 million pact as a free agent in March despite his past injury history with the Jets. His pass block win rate of 92%, according to ESPN Analytics, ranks 12th in the NFL among interior offensive linemen.


9. OLB Dre'Mont Jones: $12.1 million per year

The Patriots targeted Jones as a replacement for K'Lavon Chaisson because they viewed him as a more well-rounded edge player -- with the ability to hold his ground in the running game while also providing pass-rush spark. He has battled through a shoulder injury to play nine out of 10 games, totaling 52% of the snaps, with 19 tackles, 1.5 sacks and six quarterback hits.


10. CB Marcus Jones: $11.6 million per year

Best used in the slot on defense and as a premier punt returner, Jones has been thrust into an expanded defensive role because of Davis' neck injury. He has played 82% of the defensive snaps and has 51 tackles (fourth on the team), with one interception and one sack. Meanwhile, opponents have been careful punting to him, often angling punts to the sideline to limit his opportunities (18 returns, eight fair catches, 9.8-yard average, zero TDs).

While those account for the top 10 highest-paid Patriots, players who fall from 11 to 20 are linebacker Robert Spillane ($11 million per year), left tackle Will Campbell ($10.9 million), right guard Mike Onwenu ($10 million), Maye ($9.15 million), running back Rhamondre Stevenson ($9 million), right tackle Morgan Moses ($8.5 million), tight end Hunter Henry ($8 million), safety Kevin Byard ($7 million), linebacker Christian Elliss ($6.75 million) and tight end Julian Hill ($5 million).