Which MLB fan bases have it the worst right now? It's a question that the Sports Misery Index tackled when it originally came out in September 2018. This update has factored in the unbelievable championship run of the Washington Nationals, who became the first team to win four road games in a World Series. The Nationals obviously plummeted, leaving several fan bases in their wake and feeling downtrodden.
The Index takes into account five factors: championships, playoff berths, playoff wins, heartbreaks and rival comparison, with recent events being weighted more than events that took place decades ago. We also have a misery bonus for teams that have gone 25-plus seasons without a championship, which is something the Nats truly don't have to worry about. You can read more on the categories in the cross-sport story, but we'll identify how each MLB team rates in each category.
1. San Diego Padres
MLB movement: Even
Total score: 26.51
All-sport rank: 3 (down 1)
Ranking by category: championships, 2 (tie); playoff berths, 2; playoff wins, 1; heartbreaks, 23; rival comparison, 2

Moving forward: The Padres actually dropped in the overall standings due to a) their incremental improvement and b) the Dodgers not making the World Series for once. While they aren't quite ready to truly take on their Southern California NL West rivals, the Padres hope their building will bear a little more fruit this season.
2. Baltimore Orioles
MLB movement: Up 4
Total score: 22.23
All-sport rank: 8 (up 11)
Ranking by category: championships, 12; playoff berths, 11; playoff wins, 11; heartbreaks, 15; rival comparison, 1

Moving forward: As surprising as it is, the Orioles actually made a seven-game improvement from 2018, going from 47 to 54 wins. This team is still years away from contending, though, and incremental progress pales in comparison to watching their hated enemies hoist the past two World Series trophies. There's the Yankees, too.
3. Cincinnati Reds
MLB movement: Down 1
Total score: 20.32
All-sport rank: 11 (down 2)
Ranking by category: championships, 10; playoff berths, 5; playoff wins, 2; heartbreaks, 16; rival comparison, 7

Moving forward: The improvement the Reds saw this season isn't necessarily empty or fleeting, as Cincinnati has accumulated young talent in its farm system and has recently become aggressive in bringing in veterans such as Trevor Bauer. Don't be surprised if the Reds move above .500 and even compete for a playoff berth.
4. Chicago White Sox
MLB movement: Down 1
Total score: 19.83
All-sport rank: 13 (down 2)
Ranking by category: championships, 18; playoff berths, 1; playoff wins, 8; heartbreaks, 29; rival comparison, 4

Moving forward: Will 2020 be the year the White Sox break a playoff drought that's lasted since 2008 and make the playoffs for the 10th time in the World Series era? Signs likely point to no, but it's not as absurd a concept as it usually is. If they can get similar to slightly better improvement, the White Sox will be in the playoff hunt.
5. Seattle Mariners
MLB movement: Down 1
Total score: 19.74
All-sport rank: 14 (down 1)
Ranking by category: championships, 6; playoff berths, 3; playoff wins, 5; heartbreaks, 27; rival comparison, 12

Moving forward: Unlike the Reds and White Sox above, the Mariners are in the very early stages of a rebuild. Therefore, it's much more likely that Seattle rises in the misery list than falls in the next couple of years. M's fans might be best served watching ESPN Classic replays of Game 5 of the 1995 ALDS against the Yankees for a while.
6. Milwaukee Brewers
MLB movement: Down 1
Total score: 18.98
All-sport rank: 16 (down 1)
Ranking by category: championships, 4; playoff berths, 16; playoff wins, 13; heartbreaks, 7; rival comparison, 8

Moving forward: Two playoff seasons in a row, two brutal beats to end promising campaigns. Brewers fans know the rarity of these situations, as Milwaukee has never made three consecutive playoff appearances. So while they have NL MVP Christian Yelich, the Brew Crew has to wonder if they've already squandered their opportunity for greatness.
7. Texas Rangers
MLB movement: Even
Total score: 18.51
All-sport rank: 17 (up 4)
Ranking by category: championships, 5; playoff berths, 17; playoff wins, 16; heartbreaks, 4; rival comparison, 10

Moving forward: The Rangers played well for a while this season, thanks to a breakout year by Joey Gallo, giving them some hope going into next season. But the main thing to be excited about (besides Corey Kluber) is a new stadium with a retractable roof. So even if Texas struggles again this season, as least its fans won't be adding oppressive heat to their frustration.
8. Los Angeles Angels
MLB movement: Up 5
Total score: 17.23
All-sport rank: 22 (up 10)
Ranking by category: championships, 20; playoff berths, 7; playoff wins, 10; heartbreaks, 19; rival comparison, 5

Moving forward: While getting to watch Mike Trout is pretty awesome, the fact that the Angels are ruining his prime by being an also-ran makes the Trout era pretty unfulfilling. Perhaps hiring Joe Maddon, the guy who won a World Series with the Cubs, and signing Anthony Rendon will be what breaks the Halos out of their funk.
9. Pittsburgh Pirates
MLB movement: Down 1
Total score: 16.88
All-sport rank: 25 (down 1)
Ranking by category: championships, 7; playoff berths, 10; playoff wins, 7; heartbreaks, 12; rival comparison, 16

Moving forward: Except for a three-year stretch from 2013 to '15, Pirates baseball has been a study in frustration since Barry Bonds left after the 1992 season. That doesn't seem to be changing anytime soon, especially in an NL Central that's become much tougher to navigate the last couple of years. At least PNC Park is pretty nice.
10. Miami Marlins
MLB movement: Up 2
Total score: 16.2
All-sport rank: 28 (up 3)
Ranking by category: championships, 22; playoff berths, 4; playoff wins, 9; heartbreaks, 30; rival comparison, 11

Moving forward: Seeing former Marlins win MVPs (cough, Christian Yelich) and succeed all over the majors leaves a bad taste, especially since Miami is near rock bottom for the umpteenth time. Add that to the upward trend of the rival Rays and Braves and it's safe to say that the misery in Miami isn't going to be reversed anytime soon.
11. Toronto Blue Jays
MLB movement: Down 1
Total score: 15.7
All-sport rank: 29 (down 2)
Ranking by category: championships, 15 (tie); playoff berths, 12; playoff wins, 21; heartbreaks, 28; rival comparison, 3

Moving forward: The baseball should be pretty bad for a few more years, but the Blue Jays have young players with some pretty outstanding bloodlines. They have two sons of Hall of Famers in Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (Vladimir Guerrero) and Cavan Biggio (Craig Biggio) along with Bo Bichette, the offspring of longtime Rockies star Dante Bichette. That will help Blue Jays fans cope with the pains of rebuilding.
12. New York Mets
MLB movement: Down 1
Total score: 15.63
All-sport rank: 31 (down 1)
Ranking by category: championships, 9; playoff berths, 13; playoff wins, 20; heartbreaks, 9; rival comparison, 13

Moving forward: Can the Mets carry over their late momentum and make a real run at the playoffs in 2020? The answer to that question, as always with this team, depends on health, because there's talent to contend in the rotation (Jacob deGrom, Noah Syndergaard, Marcus Stroman, etc.), and Pete Alonso has the power-hitting ability that can carry teams for weeks at a time.
13. Colorado Rockies
MLB movement: Up 5
Total score: 15.13
All-sport rank: 32 (up 9)
Ranking by category: championships, 13; playoff berths, 15; playoff wins, 12; heartbreaks, 18; rival comparison, 9

Moving forward: With the Dodgers still loaded, it's doubtful that the Rockies will break that division-title drought this upcoming season. But Colorado still has plenty of hitters who flat rake (Nolan Arenado, Charlie Blackmon, Trevor Story). The pitching moving from awful to even mediocre could make the Rockies contenders again.
14. Philadelphia Phillies
MLB movement: Up 6
Total score: 14.34
All-sport rank: 33 (up 17)
Ranking by category: championships, 19; playoff berths, 6; playoff wins, 14; heartbreaks, 22; rival comparison, 15

Moving forward: The first Harper season was a bust, as the Phillies still haven't had a winning season since 2011. But perhaps a little more health luck and a more relaxed Harper can be the spark to get the Phillies not only above .500 but closer to the dominant level they enjoyed in the late 2000s and early 2010s.
15. Cleveland Indians
MLB movement: Up 1
Total score: 14.05
All-sport rank: 37 (up 1)
Ranking by category: championships, 1; playoff berths, 21; playoff wins, 18; heartbreaks, 2; rival comparison, 22

Moving forward: While the Indians still have talent and have been consistently good at developing their prospects, they're going to have a hard time keeping stars such as Francisco Lindor around for the long haul. Cleveland has already dealt Trevor Bauer and Corey Kluber and might be forced to make other tough decisions this upcoming season.
16. Arizona Diamondbacks
MLB movement: Up 1
Total score: 13.18
All-sport rank: 39 (even)
Ranking by category: championships, 21; playoff berths, 14; playoff wins, 15; heartbreaks, 25; rival comparison, 6

Moving forward: Unlike a lot of teams going through the rebuilding process, the Diamondbacks have gone out of their way not to completely reach bottom. They might not even come close to falling toward the back of the league, as they unearthed a star in Ketel Marte who can serve as their foundation as they bring in reinforcements like Madison Bumgarner.
17. Detroit Tigers
MLB movement: Up 2
Total score: 12.56
All-sport rank: 43 (up 4)
Ranking by category: championships, 2 (tie); playoff berths, 9; playoff wins, 19; heartbreaks, 21; rival comparison, 21

Moving forward: Tigers fans are hoping that 2019 was the absolute bottom in this rebuilding process, but their 2006-14 run of success seems like eons ago. It's going to be a while until Detroit is competitive again as it props up its farm system, so don't be surprised if the Tigers continue to shoot up this list in the next few seasons.
18. Oakland Athletics
MLB movement: Down 4
Total score: 12.0
All-sport rank: 48 (down 14)
Ranking by category: championships, 17; playoff berths, 25; playoff wins, 4; heartbreaks, 5; rival comparison, 17

Moving forward: The Beane approach has allowed the A's to remake themselves several times and have regular-season success, but that strategy hasn't produced results in the playoffs, as Oakland has lost six series in a row dating to 2006 and hasn't advanced to the World Series since 1989. Does it have one more run left in it before the next retool?
19. Tampa Bay Rays
MLB movement: Down 10
Total score: 11.58
All-sport rank: 49 (tie) (down 24)
Ranking by category: championships, 14; playoff berths, 19; playoff wins, 17; heartbreaks, 14; rival comparison, 14

Moving forward: The Rays have exciting young players who are starting to surge in Austin Meadows and Tyler Glasnow, and there's a good chance that 2018 AL Cy Young winner Blake Snell will bounce back next season. The infrastructure for another playoff run is there, even if the fan support is lacking much of the time.
20. Minnesota Twins
MLB movement: Down 5
Total score: 11.24
All-sport rank: 51 (down 16)
Ranking by category: championships, 11; playoff berths, 20; playoff wins, 3; heartbreaks, 17; rival comparison, 18

Moving forward: The Twins did a lot of great things this season behind home-run hitters such as Nelson Cruz, Max Kepler and Miguel Sano, but they weren't able to break their postseason losing streak. The sweep to the Yankees gives them 16 straight losses in playoff games dating to the 2004 ALDS. Just winning a playoff game, much less a series, is the next step.
21. Atlanta Braves
MLB movement: Up 1
Total score: 8.67
All-sport rank: 61 (up 2)
Ranking by category: championships, 8; playoff berths, 26; playoff wins, 6; heartbreaks, 8; rival comparison, 19

Moving forward: While the Game 5 no-show left a bad taste in Braves fans' mouths, the consecutive division titles show that the Baby Braves have staying power. Ronald Acuna Jr. is a perennial MVP candidate, but he's hardly the only star on the roster. Expect more October baseball and, possibly, a breakthrough against that postseason win drought.
22. Kansas City Royals
MLB movement: Up 1
Total score: 3.95
All-sport rank: 71 (up 12)
Ranking by category: championships, 27; playoff berths, 8; playoff wins, 22; heartbreaks, 20; rival comparison, 20

Moving forward: The memories of 2015 still give comfort to Royals fans, but they are going to fade with every successive losing season. Kansas City fans are used to long rebuilding and restoration processes; they just hope that this one won't turn into a nearly three-decade playoff drought like the Royals had from 1986 to 2013.
23. Los Angeles Dodgers
MLB movement: Up 1
Total score: -2.17
All-sport rank: 89 (up 4)
Ranking by category: championships, 15 (tie); playoff berths, 29; playoff wins, 24; heartbreaks, 1; rival comparison, 27

Moving forward: It seems like the Dodgers have gone all-in on being the 2.0 version of the 1990s-early 2000s Braves, as seven consecutive division titles haven't yet resulted in a World Series championship. But maybe the 2020s will get the Dodgers that first title since Kirk Gibson was limping around the bases. There's still plenty of talent.
24. Chicago Cubs
MLB movement: Up 2
Total score: -3.95
All-sport rank: 93 (up 2)
Ranking by category: championships, 25; playoff berths, 22; playoff wins, 26; heartbreaks, 10; rival comparison, 25

Moving forward: Maddon's dismissal, and subsequent hire by the Angels, sent a message: It's time to move past 2016. While a lot of Cubs fans would rather not do that (can you blame them, considering what the previous 108 years were like?), it's not all bad, as Anthony Rizzo and Kris Bryant provide the foundation for a solid lineup.
25. St. Louis Cardinals
MLB movement: Even
Total score: -8.05
All-sport rank: 103 (down 9)
Ranking by category: championships, 24; playoff berths, 28; playoff wins, 28; heartbreaks, 13; rival comparison, 26

Moving forward: The Cardinals are usually in the discussion for playoff contention, as they haven't had a losing season since 2007. Expect that trend to continue into the next decade, and with star players such as Paul Goldschmidt and Marcell Ozuna, there's a good chance the Cardinals accomplish much more.
26. San Francisco Giants
MLB movement: Up 3
Total score: -8.14
All-sport rank: 104 (up 9)
Ranking by category: championships, 29; playoff berths, 18; playoff wins, 27; heartbreaks, 26; rival comparison, 24

Moving forward: The Giants' anticipated rebuild was delayed for a year, as San Francisco unexpectedly showed some midsummer spunk and was in the wild-card race for a while. The Giants made a last-ditch effort to send Bochy out on a high note, but now that he's gone, expect the Giants to get youthful, especially with ace pitcher Madison Bumgarner departed as a free agent.
27. Houston Astros
MLB movement: Even
Total score: -11.59
All-sport rank: 109 (down 4)
Ranking by category: championships, 26; playoff berths, 24; playoff wins, 30; heartbreaks, 6; rival comparison, 30

Moving forward: Are the Astros becoming the Patriots of baseball? Houston has been innovative in compiling arguably the most talented roster in baseball, but its alleged tendency to flaunt conventions has opened itself up to criticism from other teams. If the Astros can avoid drama (the celebration fiasco after the ALCS sullied their postseason run), there's no reason this team shouldn't be a contender for years to come.
28. Washington Nationals
MLB movement: Down 7
Total score: -11.63
All-sport rank: 110 (down 50)
Ranking by category: championships, 28; playoff berths, 27; playoff wins, 23; heartbreaks, 11; rival comparison, 28

Moving forward: How do the Nationals follow up what they did this past season? Honestly, it might not matter, as Washington is playing with house money. It also helps to have pitchers such as Max Scherzer and one of the league's most promising stars in Juan Soto on your side.
29. New York Yankees
MLB movement: Down 1
Total score: -11.92
All-sport rank: 111 (up 1)
Ranking by category: championships, 23; playoff berths, 30; playoff wins, 29; heartbreaks, 3; rival comparison, 29

Moving forward: The lineup is capable of leading the Yankees to championship No. 28, but for them to get past the Astros (who have eliminated them three times since 2015), the Yanks need to boost their starting pitching. That being said, they took a big step in that direction by signing Gerrit Cole in free agency.
30. Boston Red Sox
MLB movement: Even
Total score: -12.18
All-sport rank: 112 (tie) (up 3)
Ranking by category: championships, 30; playoff berths, 23; playoff wins, 25; heartbreaks, 24; rival comparison, 23

Moving forward: The Red Sox have the offense to bounce back quickly from last year's lackluster performance; the pitching staff was the main reason Boston couldn't build any momentum. The Red Sox have a new GM, as they parted with Dave Dombrowski in the offseason, so Brian O'Halloran will be on the lookout for arms.
