With 130 all-time goals in top-tier competitions administered by the Premier Soccer League (PSL), including cups, Stellenbosch FC's Bradley Grobler is only four short of Peter Shalulile's record.
Stellenbosch head coach Gavin Hunt believes Grobler's record warranted more than the 11 Bafana Bafana caps he has received.
Hunt told ESPN, when asked about Grobler's club record relative to national team caps: "He's been a good goalscorer, you know.
"To be fair, I think he had a lot of years where he was injured quite a bit. Maybe at that point in time, he just missed the boat and that, but I certainly would have had him in the squad when he was in his 20s.
"That's for sure. There's no doubt about it, because he could do a number of things on the pitch for you. Maybe, we should have played him in a few of the away games.
"I don't know what the coaches at the time were thinking, but surely, I thought he should have had a few more caps - definitely."
What do Grobler's stats say?
As an out-and-out target man, Grobler is a rare breed of striker in South Africa.
Grobler's consistent omission from the current Bafana Bafana squad was in part due to the discretion of coaches who may not have seen his full value, but also in part due to injuries, as Hunt alluded to, and being a late bloomer.
He has hit double figures in terms of South African Premiership goals in four seasons - 2019-20 (14 goals), 2020-21 (16 goals), 2022-23 (10 goals) and 2023-24 (11 goals).
All came after his 30th birthday in 2018, and the two Bafana coaches in charge during those seasons were Molefi Ntseki (2019-2021) and Hugo Broos (2021-2026).
Ntseki fielded Grobler twice -- in November 2019 Africa Cup of Nations (AFCON) qualifiers against Ghana and Sudan -- and injury ruled the striker out of a late 2020 squad.
Ntseki was in charge of the team for nine matches and presided over the disastrous failure to qualify for AFCON 2021. Even with injury taken into account, it is difficult to explain why Ntseki used Grobler only twice when he was in the form of his life.
However, Grobler himself suggested there was more to the situation than met the eye.
"I think people don't realise there's a lot of things that go into these teams selections as well," Grobler told SNL24/Kick Off.
"Myself and Coach Molefi had a chat before the selection so I am aware of what is happening and what his thoughts are as well. So it's not as if I was totally excluded, we did speak about it - me and him - before the announcement.
"So it's for different reasons as well. I just thought that it was a good opportunity to give some younger players an opportunity to play because of the injuries that I've had the last two seasons.
"You know it may just be important to just stay at the club and then do a bit of a longer pre-season with the team and play a few friendly games before we get to qualifying and playing official matches."
It could even be argued that limited Bafana minutes in his early 30s gave Grobler the recovery time needed to score regularly at club level.
However, Grobler pulled no punches about his continued omission under Ntseki's successor, Broos, saying that he wanted to be part of the squad and was frustrated to be repeatedly overlooked.
Broos, however, can lean on one argument that Ntseki cannot: whatever the Belgian did during his time as national team boss, he got results. Bafana finished third at AFCON 2023 (held belatedly in early 2024) and made the 2026 FIFA World Cup round of 32.
At the World Cup, however, Bafana scored only twice -- and neither goalscorer (midfielder Teboho Mokoena and winger Thapelo Maseko) was a striker.
It is worth noting that of the South African-based players in Broos' squad, almost all came from the 'big three' of Mamelodi Sundowns, Orlando Pirates and Kaizer Chiefs. Ricardo Goss finished last season on loan at Siwelele from Sundowns, while Thabang Matuludi only joined Sundowns from Polokwane City after the World Cup.
It could, however, be argued that never playing for one of South Africa's traditional 'big three' meant Grobler's profile never quite reached the levels his record warranted.
Grobler was famously snubbed by Kaizer Chiefs, with the striker claiming that Amakhosi told him right before he hit the form of his life that he was past his prime. He has scored more goals against Chiefs (12 in 26 games against the Glamour Boys) than any other opponents.
The ship may have sailed for Grobler, now 38, as far as Bafana Bafana goes. Pitso Mosimane gave him his national debut in 2011 -- in which he scored the first of his two Bafana goals in a 2-1 friendly loss to Zimbabwe. However, since returning for a second stint as Bafana boss, 'Jingles' has looked elsewhere for solutions upfront.
Mosimane cannot be blamed for what happened in the years between his 2012 departure and 2026 return to the role. Still, the country's longstanding striker problem has not yet been solved, and Grobler's record at club level stands in stark contrast to the nation's fortunes in front of goal over that period.
